Why Direct Mail Is the Rodney Dangerfield of Media
If you’re in control of marketing and you’ve ignored the direct mail channel — you may be making a mistake. Easy to dismiss, for its role as a dinosaur — direct mail is the Rodney Dangerfield of media. I’ll admit that’s an almost extinct reference — but the comedian’s famous “I don’t get respect” act truly fits here. Great direct mail campaigns lead to big time sales — which — ultimately yield respect. Years ago, after starting a career in advertising, I fell in love with direct mail for the oh-so gratifying value of measurement. Now with so many options for measurable media, that tangible benefit is no longer limited to the mail.
Somewhere along the line though, gradually people began to doubt the power of the direct mail channel. Smart people. For well over a decade we have had doubters question and condescend about the dinosaur that is mail.
It’s easy to see why. After all, do people really read their mail anymore? And the cost per impression is high.
Get ready to be surprised.
And yet, like the famed Energizer Bunny, the mail channel keeps performing. For most of our clients, their direct mail program reliably brings in more lead than any other single channel. By a lot. In all of our Medicare Marketing work, the direct mail reliably drives more members and responses than any other channel. The list goes on.
There was a time that no one thought using offline media to drive online results made sense. Think again.
In fact I’d say, the best way to think about direct mail is as a sales channel. You can identify your target universe and work back from the point of sale to determine the metrics. A true cohesion among sales and marketing teams.
It’s not old news. And it’s not the only news. The really exciting part is that your mail performance can and will be enhanced by other channels
Here are some rules for determining how and when to use direct mail as part of your marketing mix:
- Do the math – Whether it be on the back-of-a-napkin, or via a comprehensive pro-forma spreadsheet, finding out in advance whether you can afford the cost of a direct mail lead is the best first step. At our agency, our teams are trained in direct mail math – those basics are “job one”!
- Start with a test – If you walk around the office showing people your mail, I can already tell you how that will go. Pretty much no one will like what could turn out to be the best performing direct mail package. Nothing beats the value of “in-market” testing.
- Feature an offer – An offer is something that goes above and beyond the product features. While an offer is not mandatory, it really helps.
- Hire an agency – This is a deceivingly detailed business. Any agency that has been in business for a number of years (with a specialty of direct mail) has faced problems. Lots of obstacles big and small that you’d rather avoid. But, beyond the value of smooth-sailing, you’ll likely get a better performing piece from a group that lives and breathes direct mail best practices. I promise it will be more than worth it.
- Hire a proofer – See #4. This is an area where you’d rather not make a mistake. It’s expensive.
Experienced direct response (and also sales) professionals honor the channel that is direct, because it’s proven itself as a valued part of the plan.
Once it works for you, you too will find yourself committed to the mail. Even if, like me, you never check your own mailbox!
Jill’s career spans 25+ years with experience in performance marketing, communications, advertising, branding and creative development. She has a track record of success in building business for national brands like Netflix, Carnival Cruise Lines, AT&T and Hyatt, as well as regional healthcare accounts such as Highmark, and Emblem Health. She has earned a reputation as a strong agency leader based on her proven ability to develop relationships and drive innovation. Proud wife, mother, sister, and daughter, Jill believes passionately in giving back and has served executive leadership roles on the Board of Directors for Family Law CASA of King County.