Open Enrollment | Subscribe to Target Marketing HERE
Connect
Follow us on
Advertisement
 

Editor's Notes : So Now Marketers Are Racists?

June 2014 By Thorin McGee
8
Get the Flash Player to see this rotator.
 

The much-anticipated White House report on Big Data may have invented an issue even more problematic to marketers than privacy: Is personalized marketing discriminatory?

"Unfortunately, 'perfect personalization' also leaves room for subtle and not-so-subtle forms of discrimination in pricing, services and opportunities," says the report (downloads as a PDF). "For example, one study found Web searches involving black-identifying names (e.g., 'Jermaine') were more likely to display ads with the word "arrest" in them than searches with white-identifying names (e.g., 'Geoffrey')."

The discrimination questions raised by the report don't stop at potentially racist corner cases. The section "Big Data and Discrimination" identifies it as a key finding:

An important conclusion of this study is that Big Data technologies can cause societal harms beyond damages to privacy, such as discrimination against individuals and groups. This discrimination can be the inadvertent outcome of the way Big Data technologies are structured and used. It can also be the result of intent to prey on vulnerable classes.

Now, after that quote, the report goes on to talk about two seemingly innocuous occurrences of inadvertent discrimination. But it soon returns to the topic of predatory discrimination and "differential pricing."

In fact, the report asserts "Consumers have a legitimate expectation of knowing whether the prices they are offered for goods and services are systematically different than the prices offered to others." It then calls for expanding the power and expertise of several government agencies to be able to identify and "resolve" cases it interprets as "discriminatory."

A few paragraphs later, the report says national security, homeland security, law enforcement and intelligence communities should "continue to vigorously experiment with and apply lawful Big Data technology."

So, once again, it appears marketers are the bogeyman being used to distract Americans from government's expanding surveillance powers.



Direct Mail

"We are highly trained, skilled postal employees, and they want to give it to employees who really don't know anything about the mail."

—John Hegarty, president of the National Postal Mail Handlers Union, during the April 24 USPS worker protest of Staples postal centers

 


 
8

SPONSORED CONTENT

MORE ON DATABASE, LISTS AND CRM >>

FROM THE BOOKSTORE

Written by Millennials about Millennials, Cause for Change: Examines how Millennials communicate, volunteer, take action, influence their peers, and choose to give their time and moneyExplains how Millennials view their role in the workplace, and how their approach is re-shaping nonprofit culture from within Cause for Change: The Why and How of Nonprofit Millennial Engagement

Written by Millennials about Millennials, Cause for Change:
Examines how Millennials communicate, volunteer, take action, influence their peers, and choose to give their time and moneyExplains how Millennials view their role in the workplace, and how their approach is re-shaping nonprofit culture from within...

ORDER NOW

Reading The Ultimate  Insider’s Guide to Winning Foundation Grants is like peeking at someone’s  secret diary or personal email.  You feel  guilty.  This is privileged information.
Only in this case Martin Teitel WANTS to reveal everything  to you. A
 long-time foundation CEO, he’s fed up with the smoke and mirrors of  
grant seeking. Ultimate Insider's Guide to Winning Foundation Grants

Reading The Ultimate Insider’s Guide to Winning Foundation Grants is like peeking at someone’s secret diary or personal email. You feel guilty. This is privileged information. Only in this case Martin Teitel WANTS to reveal everything to you. A long-time foundation CEO, he’s fed up with the smoke and mirrors of...

ORDER NOW

 

COMMENTS

Click here to leave a comment...
Comment *
Most Recent Comments: