Mindset and Measurement
In her book, "Mindset: The New Psychology of Success," Stanford University Professor Carol Dweck purports that people possess one of two mindsets: the fixed mindset or the growth mindset.
Fixed mindset people are "always trying to prove themselves and they're supersensitive about being wrong or making mistakes." They fear failure. They feel that they are always being judged. Fixed mindset people feel that they have fixed traits and talents, and that they're never going to get any better. For them, success is about proving they're smart or talented. Validating themselves.
Growth mindset people believe that "your basic qualities are things you can cultivate through your efforts." They welcome failure as a learning experience, an opportunity to grow. For them, success is about stretching themselves to learn something new. Developing themselves.
Which mindset a marketer possesses affects the way they approach testing and results measurement. Beginning my career in a traditional direct marketing environment, I learned early on that failure is a good thing. It tells you what doesn't work. I thought everyone developed tests that had limited downside risk to determine the best media, creative and offers. We roll out the winning campaign and test against it time and again. Success is always evolving.
It wasn't until I started in the agency business that I learned there was another mindset—one where in-market testing might uncover flaws in a campaign that could open it up for judgment. In the fixed marketing mindset, the agency team and the client select what they believe is the best approach. If time and money permit, then perhaps they do some research to validate their choice. But as David Ogilvy pointed out so many years ago, "Research is often misused by agencies and their clients. They have a way of using it to prove they are right. They use research as a drunkard uses a lamppost—not for illumination but for support."