Mine your best-performing e-mails for ideas on what kind of content to offer to disengaged subscribers.
Better yet, identify groups of now-disengaged subscribers who likely share an interest in specific areas of your business, based on their past click activity and/or demographics. Segment your disengaged subscribers, and approach each group with a different angle.
4. Don't give up after the first try. Even when subscribers were engaged, they didn't open or click on every e-mail. And they won't all open/click on your first re-engagement try.
Approach re-engagement as a sequence of two to three e-mails. Send the second message to people who didn't respond to the first one, and the third to people who didn't respond to the second one. Starting with the second message, let subscribers know that if they don't respond, they will no longer receive the benefits of your e-mails. Use the last message in your sequence as a clear, urgent notification that subscribers are hearing from you for the last time unless they respond.
5. Know when to let go. No matter how good your re-engagement campaign is, not everyone is going to respond to it. In fact, odds are good that more than half of the subscribers you target with it will not respond to any of your re-engagement e-mails.
Rather than seeing this as a loss, recognize it as affirmation that there is no point to keeping these "dead weight" subscribers on your list. Remind yourself that a bloated, unresponsive list is bad for response rates and deliverability. And move forward with the subscribers who still want to hear from you.
Justin Premick is the director of education marketing at AWeber Communications, a provider of on-demand e-mail marketing software. He spearheads AWeber's efforts to teach businesses how to build lasting customer relationships via permission-based email marketing. He can be reached at justinpremick@aweber.com.




Social Media ROI
Email Marketing that Works (2nd Edition)