Target Marketing

You will be automatically redirected to targetmarketingmag in 20 seconds.
Skip this advertisement.

Advertisement
Advertisement
 
 

17 Hours in the Real America

On the Road—the Railroad, That Is

October 2007 By Denny Hatch
23

In the News

HOLIDAY PRIMER
Over the River and Through the Roof …
Planning to travel this holiday season? You better watch out.
Here are some ways to make travel during the busy months ahead a little more bearable.

* Ride the rails. If traveling in the Northeast, consider taking the train. Advantages include a less restrictive pre-departure arrival time (45 minutes recommended for holidays), carry-on allowances of two 50-pound bags, en-route mobility, a dining car and no road rage. According to Amtrak manager Tracy Connell, the busiest days are the Tuesday before and the Sunday after Thanksgiving. Travel is more spread out around Christmas and New Year’s, and you can save money by traveling during off-peak hours (early morning or late evening). Generally, Connell says train stations also are less busy on New Year’s Eve and New Year’s Day than on the preceding three or four days. Reservations are required for all trips, and although Amtrak adds trains during the holidays, prime times can sell out. Info: 800-872-7245, http://www.amtrak.com.
—Kristin Harrison, The Washington Post, October 21, 2007
On Friday, October 12 my wife, Peggy, and I took the overnight train out of Washington’s Union Station bound for Chicago and the Direct Marketing Association conference and exhibition.

The following Wednesday, we flew home: Up at 5:30 a.m.; traffic jam during the taxi ride to O’Hare; hefting our bags to check-in at US Airways; being treated like terrorists by screeners; calorie-laden breakfast at Chili’s with plastic eating utensils; two hours in the crowded waiting room amidst loud cell phone yappers; middle seats in a sealed aluminum tube and hurled at 500 mph across the country for two hours; exit madness with apprehension over the possibility of lost luggage; and taxi home.

Six hours of hellish travel, and I should be grateful; everything was on time and our luggage made it.

Every time I glanced out the window during the flight and saw Mother Earth 35,000 feet below, I thought, “So much is happening down there, and I’m missing it all.”

A Love Affair with Trains
When I was a kid in the early 1940s, once a year we would travel by train from New York to visit my grandmother in Los Angeles, where she was a voice teacher—overnight to Chicago and two days on the Santa Fe Chief to L.A. To Peggy’s irritation and my delight, our everyday dinnerware is reproduction Santa Fe Railroad dining car china.

In 1949 I spent six weeks in Las Vegas with my father who needed to establish residence so he could divorce my mother. We stayed at the adobe Boulderado Dude Ranch (currently the oldest standing structure in Las Vegas), and every evening at sunset we would watch the Union Pacific train to Chicago pass by in the distance like a tiny HO model with the windows lighted. As his six weeks was drawing to a close, I asked my father if we could take that train back and he agreed. Instead of going to the Las Vegas train station, we drove down to the railroad tracks and flagged down the train. As the noisy monster slowed to a halt, a door in one of the passenger cars opened and a conductor appeared with a little metal stool. He took our grips and we boarded right there in the middle of the desert.

(Quick Query: Has any reader ever flagged down a transcontinental train and boarded it in the middle of nowhere? Tell us about it.)

Takeaway Points to Consider:

* America’s greatest achievers made their contributions—and their fortunes—prior to cell phones and BlackBerrys: Edison, Henry Luce, Donald Douglas, Frank Lloyd Wright, Bill Gates and Steve Jobs, to name a few.

* Are the perpetually-connected people furiously thumbing BlackBerrys and yakking on cell phones thinking? Or are they simply reacting and acting? Is this the best way to grow a business and further a career? After all, the world’s most successful entrepreneur—and the third richest person—Warren Buffett, does not have a computer on his desk.

* “If you are a marketer, take the bus, subway, train or streetcar to work. These are the real Americans that you want to reach with your messages.”
—Axel Andersson

* “THINK.”
Thomas J. Watson (1874-1956), president of IBM (née International Business Machines Corp.)

* Unless you are willing to spend thousands of dollars for a few hours of comfort on all-business-class airlines or private jets, expect your commercial airline experience to start at mediocre and go downhill from there.

* Why not reconnect with your country, and its people—the real America. Try an overnight train. You might even reconnect with yourself.

Web Sites Related to Today's Edition:

Capitol Limited
http://tinyurl.com/322c5p

Amtrak Accommodations
http://tinyurl.com/3yh4cc

Santa Fe Railroad Dining Car China
http://www.dallasrailwaymuseum.com/railroadchina.html
 
23

COMMENTS

Click here to leave a comment...
Comment *
Most Recent Comments:
Neil Lichtman - Posted on November 22, 2007
I don't have time to read stuff like this - but I did. I love my "roomette" trips from NYC to CHI to a client. I get there between 9 and 10 and have had a full night's sleep and nice meals. Quite a difference from having to get up at 4:30 AM to arrive at the same time after being harassed all the way, being tired and perhaps grumpy.

I agree completely. Rail should be improved instead of constantly threatening to reduce subsidies.
Jack - Posted on October 26, 2007
Denny, you can still flag down and board a couple of cross country trains I have ridden in the past few years. We flagged the TransCanada train down in British Columbia and boarded with a canoe, packs and fishing poles. (and carrying a compact, high caliber rifle slung over my shoulder) Although I have never flagged down the Alaskan Railway, I have seen it done just this summer. It is a common practice for those rural people who use the train to get to Anchorage and back.

In July I took the Alaskan Railway from Fairbanks to Anchorage, a leisurely 12 hour trip where our stewards and staff all changed with a north bound train at a halfway point. The staff that travels the north half of the route each day live in Fairbanks and the staff for the south half of the journey live in Anchorage. So all the crew and staff are at home with their families every night.

I paid the $300 price for the 1st class luxury for the 12 hour trip and we were elevated above our dining car and had a wonderful view of the incredible countryside! We had the white tablecloths, but our china and crystal were real and not plastic. Our steward provided free drinks throughout the trip and there was an outdoor viewing area where we could let the wind blow in our faces and snap photos without worrying about window glare.

And the company was wonderful... everyone even passed around their digital cameras sharing photos we had taken during our travels in Alaska.

I cannot recommend this trip highly enough!

I also regularly take the Z train between Beijing and Xian China which is a high speed 12 hour nonstop trip leaving at 6:00 PM and arriving at 6:00 AM. It is quiet, with a comfortable berth, fine dining car, and stewards cleaning the restrooms after each person. (western style in front of each car and Asian in rear of each car) It was on this train I met and spent a coup
Martine - Posted on October 24, 2007
Until rail travel becomes true "mass" transit, it will remain underutilized. A shame, since I suspect that an entire generation is out there willing to be seduced into becoming "train buffs," if it weren't so inconvenient. Three brief examples:
1. I can't take the train to evening class at the local university; the class gets out after the trains have stopped running.

Similarly, we can't take the train to the ball game, though there's a station right at the stadium parking lot. Again, trains quit running before the game lets out.

2. When my company can spend pennies to reimburse a carpool driver for gas, why fork out $16.00 per traveler to send a group to a trade event one county up the map?

3. One young (20-something) colleague has a train station a block from her home, and two miles from her office. But there is no bus stop near the office. My friend would willingly walk, but a great portion of the two miles is along a large, busy thoroughfare, with NO sidewalk!

Right now rail travel as a realistic means of convenient trasportation in this country remains outside the mainstream. Too bad. I'd love to give my kids the experience.
Fred Lederman - Posted on October 24, 2007
Denny-

Thanks for another terrific and insightful article. Now I know why you looked so relaxed when I stopped by your booth at the DMA Show last week?rail travel!

Rail travel is a truly magical experience where travelers can experience the beauty and the social gradients of a country as it gently rocks by their windows; engage the various people as they come and go at different stations; and, breathe in the flavors of life.

Many critics of rail transportation have declared its demise. Rail travel isn?t dead. It was just taking a nap, waiting for a point in time when the world?s thirst for fossil fuels made all other forms of travel too expensive and too big a hassle. Like the Phoenix, rail travel will arise from the ashes of financial oblivion, public indifference and the consumers? need for immediate gratification to become our country?s most cost efficient and productive form of transportation. To corrupt a quotation by a former and late Prime Minister of the United Arab Emirates, ?My great grandfather rode a train, my grandfather rode ?the El?, my father drove a Buick, I drive a Mercedes, my children will drive Toyotas and my grandchildren will ride trains.?

For example, the Acela is rapidly becoming a commuter business center for the New York to Washington, D.C. Corridor and points in between. With upscale dining cars, first class service that allows for small business meetings in relatively plush surroundings?this is the wave of the future.

The next step may well be Amtrak conference/business center cars for larger meetings. These railcars will be equipped with full Internet connectivity, fax machines, copiers, audio-video presentation equipment and catering services. Companies will be able to hold multi-city client meetings, training sessions and internal briefings on Amtrak which will be productive, cost effective,
Margaret - Posted on October 24, 2007
I loved this column, Denny. I too adore traveling by train. Can't stand planes and airports (except for the people-watching). But I must confess -- and this will seem horrific to some -- that my absolute best travel experience was three days cross-country (and three more days back) from Philly to LA on Greyhound. Yes, the bus.

Of course, I was much younger (early 20s) with a lot less luggage and a lot more flexibility. Talk about getting up-close-and-personal. The people I met, the stories I heard. It was amazing. And the scenery! Purple mountains, fruited plains -- everything you hear about in the song and more. Passing by you at an even slower pace than on the train. And the rest stops -- each dripping with local flavor, character and characters.

Whether it's on a train or a bus, there is something strangely magical about falling asleep and then waking up and not knowing exactly where you are. Did we cross a state line? Without asking anyone, how can I figure out where I am?

I feel very sad when I see folks -- obviously leisure travelers with little or no agenda to stick to -- sitting in an airport terminal with their backpacks waiting for a domestic flight. They just don't know what they're missing by not being on a train or even a bus.
Max Bendel - Posted on October 24, 2007
A slight content correction, from my experience as a youthful trailer jockey, trucking companies pay road taxes. If I remember correctly, something like thousands a year, and that does not include fuel taxes and road tolls.
Brent D. Gardner, CLU, ChFC - Posted on October 23, 2007
Just a few weeks ago, I wrote a blog about how Europe, Japan, et al. have an advantage over us with their continued investment in high speed passenger trains. When I see the right-of-ways being stolen from their real owners (out here in the Midwest, they were "borrowed" or "lifetime leased" from the bona fide deed holders), and turned into bike/hike paths that maybe get used by 0.0001% of the population, I think we're making a huge mistake. Every week for the last month, I've endured the excrutiating process of flying commercial, and I've grown to hate the it with a passion. I personally think the TSA is the biggest flop of the last decade, and nobody can convince me I'm safer because of the new legion of government employees.
Nick Wrathall - Posted on October 23, 2007
Dear Denny,
In total agreement, as is usually the case with your excellent articles. The train is far superior to any other mode of transport, except perhaps the bicycle and one's own two feet! Whether it's the TGV in France, the Trans-European ICE trains, the Shinkansen (Bullet Train) in Japan or The Orient Express, all of which I've been fortunate enough to travel on, you would be hard pressed to enjoy any other form of transport, with the added bonus of an invariably polite onboard staff (and no 'shoes off before you board' either...Ted, couldn't agree with you more). And last but not least, a London to Paris Eurostar trip to look forward to this Friday - can't wait!
Keep up the good work.
Yours sincerely,
Nick Wrathall
London, England
Tom Cannon - Posted on October 23, 2007
Denny,
During my Army career, I spent 11 years in Europe. The trains there are magnificent and we could do the same here. Up to 600 miles a train ride competes very well with the airlines. Beyond that, an airline is "quicker" but still not better. There is a writer named James Howard Kunstler who writes extensively on US development since WW II. His books include "The Geography of Nowhere" and "The Long Emergency." One of his recurring themes is that passenger trains can play a vital role in maintaining our country and civilization in the face of ever rising oil prices. Check out his weekly blog, it's certainly not dull or staid! As for our plutocracy, politicans, and network talking heads: some time on a train or a Greyhound Bus would be a shock to their system, but they may learn something. Thanks for a GREAT column!
Tom Cannon, Savannah, GA.
Peter Rosenwald - Posted on October 23, 2007
You're absolutely right -- as usual.

The train certainly beats flying. For example, now Eurostar races through the beautiful English countryside, plunges under the Channel and then whizzes through France, ending up in the center of Paris. It's quicker and much nicer than flying.

And the security, while thorough, is courteous and efficient, totally unlike the last flight out of Miami where as a result of my pacemaker, I wasn't able to go through the electronic scanner and had to tolerate an abusive examiner who insisted I take my belt off and put both my arms out. Sensing that this might cause an inadvertent indecent exposure, I suggested one arm at a time while I held up my trousers with the other. I was immediately threatened with arrest for failing to follow orders.

Is this what US travel has come to?
Rob Formica - Posted on October 23, 2007
I agree about how our gov't subsidizes planes and trucks at the expense of trains. However, I submit that if trains ever became as popular as they ought to be, they would immediatly become subject to all the security and such that we hate about planes!
Paul - Posted on October 23, 2007
I've taken trains overnight a few times, between Phila. & the deep South, and it was an interesting experience seeing a part of America at a much slower pace, and taking in more of the details. I think of all the movers & shakers in the business & governmental worlds who have developed such a misunderstanding, if not contempt, of "flyover country".
Anthony Green - Posted on October 23, 2007
Denny, you are an incurable romantic!
I have always produced good ad copy on trains. The Brirish Poet Laurate, the late Sir John Betjeman, wrote most of his work on trains. The random passing of objects, shapes, people, events, colours, etc shakes up the imagination and produces thoughts unbounded by four walls. It's like a moving one man brain storming session. A lovely piece.
Anthony Green
Ted - Posted on October 23, 2007
As I have come to expect, another wonderfully enjoyable column! I just flew from Philadelphia to Atlanta for the weekend to see a sick family member, and I spent nearly every second on the plane wishing I had taken the train instead. To add to the irony, because I am researching a business idea with trains at the epicenter, I was reading a book about America's Railroad! My longest trips on the rails have been NYC to DC, but I've enjoyed every one of them. I would love to see someone find a way to make a go of providing rail service to business travelers. Meeting cars? Mini office suites? Someone please save me from the mile long line I suffer all for the pleasure of stripping myself of shoes, belt, jacket, wallet, laptop, cell phone, keys, watch, and change (not to mention making sure all my toiletries are less than 3 ounces and in a quart-size ziplock bag) so I can spend hours in a germ-recycling tin can stuffed into a seat that would seem at home in an interrogation cell. One would think at the very least we could find a way to use all the time we save (?) by having our cell phones and Blackberries to travel by train...
Tracy Cox - Posted on October 23, 2007
Mr Hatch,

I appreciate your flavorfull works of expression recalling your tain experienc. I feel like I was there with you and your wife. (don't worry I'm engaged). I believe that the government needs to step in and provide more funding in our train system. I believe as yoiu mentioned that this would help us in becomming more green. I have receintly been taking the Amtrak train from Detroit to Chicago and it has been a nightmare!. What should have only taken 6 hours turns into 12 quite frequently. If the governemnt could begin to step in I think I would take the train more often, untill then, no way!
Chris Altwegg - Posted on October 23, 2007
Ah, trains. Two great trips to take: Portland, Or to Minneapolis; leave at 4:45 in the afternoon and travel along the Columbia River till dark, wake up to Glacier National Park, and you'll really see why Montana is called Big Sky Country. Or travel from Seattle to Santa Barbara on Coast Starlight. Incredible scenery in Northern California, followed later by riding right next to the Pacific for miles and miles as you approach SB. Everything you said about trains, good and bad is correct in my opinion. Airplans and car are movement, but trains are travel and relaxation. Plus you meet some of the nicest people riding them!
Betsey Hartford - Posted on October 23, 2007
I also took the train to Chicago (from Boston) two years ago to go to Graph Expo (a great show for marketers as well as printers). It was the anniversary of 9/11 and I just didn't feel like flying, especially from Logan. The train trip was wonderful ? much as you describe. It was so nice to have 20 hours to read (I finished Haruki Murakami's terrific novel, "The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle" about the Japanese invasion of Mongolia), to chat with other passengers at meals, and sleep. Waking up to passing cornfields alone was worth the trip. I was surprised that almost all of my fellow passengers were there because of a fear of flying. There are so many other reasons to take the train. I've been planing it since, but hope to have the time to take the train again.
Michael Hofmann - Posted on October 23, 2007
I've traveled quite a lot across N. Europe via train, and it is a lovely experience.
Arrive 5 minutes before departure, great scenery-you can see the culture through the window.
As long as our culture thinks faster = quality = better, life will pass us by as we fly by in those planes high above and far away from it all.
Best regards Denny; nice to meet you in Chicago.
Michael
John Bergh - Posted on October 23, 2007
Hi,
Enjoyed this story very much! It's been quite a few years since we did similar travel midwest to west coast; a great experience.
I really think that rail freight will return as a better mode of shipping, more efficient and economical. Time to buy real estate with rail access!
Ben Gay III - Posted on October 23, 2007
Denny - You brought back a lot of fond memories from my childhood. Traveling by train in the 40s/50s was a magical experience for a young boy. - Ben Gay III
Mark - Posted on October 23, 2007
Truly enjoyed this one, Mr. Hatch. Thank you again!
S. Rhoades - Posted on October 23, 2007
My son moved from our home in central Illinois to Colorado. Two or three times a year I travel overnight by train to visit. It is extremely relaxing and a comfortable stress free way to travel. Shame on this country for letting our rail system deteriorate. Of the money our governement throws around like so much trash some of the best spent goes to Amtrak.
Diane Christy - Posted on October 23, 2007
I lived in West Germany for 5 years and have traveled back to Europe twice. The best part was the train system. You really CAN set your watch by the trains. Luxurious, beautiful views, always end up in the heart of town. Glorious. We loved schlepping our food with us, meeting people, stopping on a whim (we used Eurail passes) and the amazing civility of train travel. Hard to understand why we can't use/expand train travel when the vast infrastructure is already in place. Great story, Denny.
Click here to view archived comments...
Archived Comments:
Neil Lichtman - Posted on November 22, 2007
I don't have time to read stuff like this - but I did. I love my "roomette" trips from NYC to CHI to a client. I get there between 9 and 10 and have had a full night's sleep and nice meals. Quite a difference from having to get up at 4:30 AM to arrive at the same time after being harassed all the way, being tired and perhaps grumpy.

I agree completely. Rail should be improved instead of constantly threatening to reduce subsidies.
Jack - Posted on October 26, 2007
Denny, you can still flag down and board a couple of cross country trains I have ridden in the past few years. We flagged the TransCanada train down in British Columbia and boarded with a canoe, packs and fishing poles. (and carrying a compact, high caliber rifle slung over my shoulder) Although I have never flagged down the Alaskan Railway, I have seen it done just this summer. It is a common practice for those rural people who use the train to get to Anchorage and back.

In July I took the Alaskan Railway from Fairbanks to Anchorage, a leisurely 12 hour trip where our stewards and staff all changed with a north bound train at a halfway point. The staff that travels the north half of the route each day live in Fairbanks and the staff for the south half of the journey live in Anchorage. So all the crew and staff are at home with their families every night.

I paid the $300 price for the 1st class luxury for the 12 hour trip and we were elevated above our dining car and had a wonderful view of the incredible countryside! We had the white tablecloths, but our china and crystal were real and not plastic. Our steward provided free drinks throughout the trip and there was an outdoor viewing area where we could let the wind blow in our faces and snap photos without worrying about window glare.

And the company was wonderful... everyone even passed around their digital cameras sharing photos we had taken during our travels in Alaska.

I cannot recommend this trip highly enough!

I also regularly take the Z train between Beijing and Xian China which is a high speed 12 hour nonstop trip leaving at 6:00 PM and arriving at 6:00 AM. It is quiet, with a comfortable berth, fine dining car, and stewards cleaning the restrooms after each person. (western style in front of each car and Asian in rear of each car) It was on this train I met and spent a coup
Martine - Posted on October 24, 2007
Until rail travel becomes true "mass" transit, it will remain underutilized. A shame, since I suspect that an entire generation is out there willing to be seduced into becoming "train buffs," if it weren't so inconvenient. Three brief examples:
1. I can't take the train to evening class at the local university; the class gets out after the trains have stopped running.

Similarly, we can't take the train to the ball game, though there's a station right at the stadium parking lot. Again, trains quit running before the game lets out.

2. When my company can spend pennies to reimburse a carpool driver for gas, why fork out $16.00 per traveler to send a group to a trade event one county up the map?

3. One young (20-something) colleague has a train station a block from her home, and two miles from her office. But there is no bus stop near the office. My friend would willingly walk, but a great portion of the two miles is along a large, busy thoroughfare, with NO sidewalk!

Right now rail travel as a realistic means of convenient trasportation in this country remains outside the mainstream. Too bad. I'd love to give my kids the experience.
Fred Lederman - Posted on October 24, 2007
Denny-

Thanks for another terrific and insightful article. Now I know why you looked so relaxed when I stopped by your booth at the DMA Show last week?rail travel!

Rail travel is a truly magical experience where travelers can experience the beauty and the social gradients of a country as it gently rocks by their windows; engage the various people as they come and go at different stations; and, breathe in the flavors of life.

Many critics of rail transportation have declared its demise. Rail travel isn?t dead. It was just taking a nap, waiting for a point in time when the world?s thirst for fossil fuels made all other forms of travel too expensive and too big a hassle. Like the Phoenix, rail travel will arise from the ashes of financial oblivion, public indifference and the consumers? need for immediate gratification to become our country?s most cost efficient and productive form of transportation. To corrupt a quotation by a former and late Prime Minister of the United Arab Emirates, ?My great grandfather rode a train, my grandfather rode ?the El?, my father drove a Buick, I drive a Mercedes, my children will drive Toyotas and my grandchildren will ride trains.?

For example, the Acela is rapidly becoming a commuter business center for the New York to Washington, D.C. Corridor and points in between. With upscale dining cars, first class service that allows for small business meetings in relatively plush surroundings?this is the wave of the future.

The next step may well be Amtrak conference/business center cars for larger meetings. These railcars will be equipped with full Internet connectivity, fax machines, copiers, audio-video presentation equipment and catering services. Companies will be able to hold multi-city client meetings, training sessions and internal briefings on Amtrak which will be productive, cost effective,
Margaret - Posted on October 24, 2007
I loved this column, Denny. I too adore traveling by train. Can't stand planes and airports (except for the people-watching). But I must confess -- and this will seem horrific to some -- that my absolute best travel experience was three days cross-country (and three more days back) from Philly to LA on Greyhound. Yes, the bus.

Of course, I was much younger (early 20s) with a lot less luggage and a lot more flexibility. Talk about getting up-close-and-personal. The people I met, the stories I heard. It was amazing. And the scenery! Purple mountains, fruited plains -- everything you hear about in the song and more. Passing by you at an even slower pace than on the train. And the rest stops -- each dripping with local flavor, character and characters.

Whether it's on a train or a bus, there is something strangely magical about falling asleep and then waking up and not knowing exactly where you are. Did we cross a state line? Without asking anyone, how can I figure out where I am?

I feel very sad when I see folks -- obviously leisure travelers with little or no agenda to stick to -- sitting in an airport terminal with their backpacks waiting for a domestic flight. They just don't know what they're missing by not being on a train or even a bus.
Max Bendel - Posted on October 24, 2007
A slight content correction, from my experience as a youthful trailer jockey, trucking companies pay road taxes. If I remember correctly, something like thousands a year, and that does not include fuel taxes and road tolls.
Brent D. Gardner, CLU, ChFC - Posted on October 23, 2007
Just a few weeks ago, I wrote a blog about how Europe, Japan, et al. have an advantage over us with their continued investment in high speed passenger trains. When I see the right-of-ways being stolen from their real owners (out here in the Midwest, they were "borrowed" or "lifetime leased" from the bona fide deed holders), and turned into bike/hike paths that maybe get used by 0.0001% of the population, I think we're making a huge mistake. Every week for the last month, I've endured the excrutiating process of flying commercial, and I've grown to hate the it with a passion. I personally think the TSA is the biggest flop of the last decade, and nobody can convince me I'm safer because of the new legion of government employees.
Nick Wrathall - Posted on October 23, 2007
Dear Denny,
In total agreement, as is usually the case with your excellent articles. The train is far superior to any other mode of transport, except perhaps the bicycle and one's own two feet! Whether it's the TGV in France, the Trans-European ICE trains, the Shinkansen (Bullet Train) in Japan or The Orient Express, all of which I've been fortunate enough to travel on, you would be hard pressed to enjoy any other form of transport, with the added bonus of an invariably polite onboard staff (and no 'shoes off before you board' either...Ted, couldn't agree with you more). And last but not least, a London to Paris Eurostar trip to look forward to this Friday - can't wait!
Keep up the good work.
Yours sincerely,
Nick Wrathall
London, England
Tom Cannon - Posted on October 23, 2007
Denny,
During my Army career, I spent 11 years in Europe. The trains there are magnificent and we could do the same here. Up to 600 miles a train ride competes very well with the airlines. Beyond that, an airline is "quicker" but still not better. There is a writer named James Howard Kunstler who writes extensively on US development since WW II. His books include "The Geography of Nowhere" and "The Long Emergency." One of his recurring themes is that passenger trains can play a vital role in maintaining our country and civilization in the face of ever rising oil prices. Check out his weekly blog, it's certainly not dull or staid! As for our plutocracy, politicans, and network talking heads: some time on a train or a Greyhound Bus would be a shock to their system, but they may learn something. Thanks for a GREAT column!
Tom Cannon, Savannah, GA.
Peter Rosenwald - Posted on October 23, 2007
You're absolutely right -- as usual.

The train certainly beats flying. For example, now Eurostar races through the beautiful English countryside, plunges under the Channel and then whizzes through France, ending up in the center of Paris. It's quicker and much nicer than flying.

And the security, while thorough, is courteous and efficient, totally unlike the last flight out of Miami where as a result of my pacemaker, I wasn't able to go through the electronic scanner and had to tolerate an abusive examiner who insisted I take my belt off and put both my arms out. Sensing that this might cause an inadvertent indecent exposure, I suggested one arm at a time while I held up my trousers with the other. I was immediately threatened with arrest for failing to follow orders.

Is this what US travel has come to?
Rob Formica - Posted on October 23, 2007
I agree about how our gov't subsidizes planes and trucks at the expense of trains. However, I submit that if trains ever became as popular as they ought to be, they would immediatly become subject to all the security and such that we hate about planes!
Paul - Posted on October 23, 2007
I've taken trains overnight a few times, between Phila. & the deep South, and it was an interesting experience seeing a part of America at a much slower pace, and taking in more of the details. I think of all the movers & shakers in the business & governmental worlds who have developed such a misunderstanding, if not contempt, of "flyover country".
Anthony Green - Posted on October 23, 2007
Denny, you are an incurable romantic!
I have always produced good ad copy on trains. The Brirish Poet Laurate, the late Sir John Betjeman, wrote most of his work on trains. The random passing of objects, shapes, people, events, colours, etc shakes up the imagination and produces thoughts unbounded by four walls. It's like a moving one man brain storming session. A lovely piece.
Anthony Green
Ted - Posted on October 23, 2007
As I have come to expect, another wonderfully enjoyable column! I just flew from Philadelphia to Atlanta for the weekend to see a sick family member, and I spent nearly every second on the plane wishing I had taken the train instead. To add to the irony, because I am researching a business idea with trains at the epicenter, I was reading a book about America's Railroad! My longest trips on the rails have been NYC to DC, but I've enjoyed every one of them. I would love to see someone find a way to make a go of providing rail service to business travelers. Meeting cars? Mini office suites? Someone please save me from the mile long line I suffer all for the pleasure of stripping myself of shoes, belt, jacket, wallet, laptop, cell phone, keys, watch, and change (not to mention making sure all my toiletries are less than 3 ounces and in a quart-size ziplock bag) so I can spend hours in a germ-recycling tin can stuffed into a seat that would seem at home in an interrogation cell. One would think at the very least we could find a way to use all the time we save (?) by having our cell phones and Blackberries to travel by train...
Tracy Cox - Posted on October 23, 2007
Mr Hatch,

I appreciate your flavorfull works of expression recalling your tain experienc. I feel like I was there with you and your wife. (don't worry I'm engaged). I believe that the government needs to step in and provide more funding in our train system. I believe as yoiu mentioned that this would help us in becomming more green. I have receintly been taking the Amtrak train from Detroit to Chicago and it has been a nightmare!. What should have only taken 6 hours turns into 12 quite frequently. If the governemnt could begin to step in I think I would take the train more often, untill then, no way!
Chris Altwegg - Posted on October 23, 2007
Ah, trains. Two great trips to take: Portland, Or to Minneapolis; leave at 4:45 in the afternoon and travel along the Columbia River till dark, wake up to Glacier National Park, and you'll really see why Montana is called Big Sky Country. Or travel from Seattle to Santa Barbara on Coast Starlight. Incredible scenery in Northern California, followed later by riding right next to the Pacific for miles and miles as you approach SB. Everything you said about trains, good and bad is correct in my opinion. Airplans and car are movement, but trains are travel and relaxation. Plus you meet some of the nicest people riding them!
Betsey Hartford - Posted on October 23, 2007
I also took the train to Chicago (from Boston) two years ago to go to Graph Expo (a great show for marketers as well as printers). It was the anniversary of 9/11 and I just didn't feel like flying, especially from Logan. The train trip was wonderful ? much as you describe. It was so nice to have 20 hours to read (I finished Haruki Murakami's terrific novel, "The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle" about the Japanese invasion of Mongolia), to chat with other passengers at meals, and sleep. Waking up to passing cornfields alone was worth the trip. I was surprised that almost all of my fellow passengers were there because of a fear of flying. There are so many other reasons to take the train. I've been planing it since, but hope to have the time to take the train again.
Michael Hofmann - Posted on October 23, 2007
I've traveled quite a lot across N. Europe via train, and it is a lovely experience.
Arrive 5 minutes before departure, great scenery-you can see the culture through the window.
As long as our culture thinks faster = quality = better, life will pass us by as we fly by in those planes high above and far away from it all.
Best regards Denny; nice to meet you in Chicago.
Michael
John Bergh - Posted on October 23, 2007
Hi,
Enjoyed this story very much! It's been quite a few years since we did similar travel midwest to west coast; a great experience.
I really think that rail freight will return as a better mode of shipping, more efficient and economical. Time to buy real estate with rail access!
Ben Gay III - Posted on October 23, 2007
Denny - You brought back a lot of fond memories from my childhood. Traveling by train in the 40s/50s was a magical experience for a young boy. - Ben Gay III
Mark - Posted on October 23, 2007
Truly enjoyed this one, Mr. Hatch. Thank you again!
S. Rhoades - Posted on October 23, 2007
My son moved from our home in central Illinois to Colorado. Two or three times a year I travel overnight by train to visit. It is extremely relaxing and a comfortable stress free way to travel. Shame on this country for letting our rail system deteriorate. Of the money our governement throws around like so much trash some of the best spent goes to Amtrak.
Diane Christy - Posted on October 23, 2007
I lived in West Germany for 5 years and have traveled back to Europe twice. The best part was the train system. You really CAN set your watch by the trains. Luxurious, beautiful views, always end up in the heart of town. Glorious. We loved schlepping our food with us, meeting people, stopping on a whim (we used Eurail passes) and the amazing civility of train travel. Hard to understand why we can't use/expand train travel when the vast infrastructure is already in place. Great story, Denny.